The Central Park Spire, Revisited

Nordstrom Spire

(The Spire-less Nordstrom Tower, after an unfortunate design change. Rendering, 2015)

The Urban Critic: Recently, it was revealed that the crowning spire of the soon to rise Nordstrom Tower has been deleted from its design, leaving in its wake another tall glass box with nondescript features.

A year ago in our prior post, The Central Park Spire, we praised the new Supertall for projecting a futuristic & strong profile into the Manhattan skyline. In our era of Supertall skyscrapers, this design, while boxy and predictable at its base and mid section, took on a stronger profile as it crept skyward. It was a gesture toward the audacity of earlier skyscrapers of the 20th Century and a nod that Manhattan was again pushing the upper limits of tall building design.

For reasons likely tied to budget, the spire has been lopped off the top and we are left with another basic box, albeit a very tall one, with a nonexistent crown. It no longer captures the imagination as the once-future-tallest of The City would have.

217-West-57th-Street-South

(The Nordstrom Spire, with its loftier design. Rendering circa 2014)

Oftentimes, with structures of this scale, ballooning budgets leave the last elements of construction to be reconsidered. A spire is an easy target for a building that may also be a target in itself. As architecture, this is a reversal of a design whose base and shaft seemed to exist for the sole purpose of supporting a higher reaching element. In totality, it feels similar to lopping off the arm of The Statue of Liberty, both in proportion and message.

We ask to bring back the Central Park Spire, so it is a beacon for all who travel to The City from afar, as well as disilliusioned Urban Dwellers. Sometimes looking up is the best medicine; And the many spires of New York serve to keep that raw energy burning.

Prior Posts on The Supertalls of New York:

The Central Park Spire. A blog post where we praised the Nordstrom Tower Spire, from 2014.

Imagination City. Thoughts on the impact of Supertalls on The Urban Skyline, from May 2015.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s